CopyLeft Commies

I guess that I’m a Copyleft commie, if you believe Bill Gates. Here’s Bill’s comment that launched a thousand blogs:

"No, I’d say that of the world’s economies, there’s more that believe in intellectual property today than ever. There are fewer communists in the world today than there were. There are some new modern-day sort of communists who want to get rid of the incentive for musicians and moviemakers and software makers under various guises. They don’t think that those incentives should exist."

Follow this with Michelle Delio’s overview of some of the issues around patents and open source:


  • Recently
    IBM just gave a few hundred of them [patents] away while other companies are greedily gobbling them up.
  • The issue – "The real story here is that we are in the midst of a huge revolution because the patent system hasn’t kept up with technology and changes in society," says Sunstein [an attorney specializing in intellectual property law].

On the other hand, Creative Commons offers creators an option to control their own copyright – With a Creative Commons license, you keep your copyright but allow people to copy and distribute your work provided they give you credit — and only on the conditions you specify here.

There is also a Canadian petition circulating on user’s rights, which gives a different perspective from what one hears from the established media companies. If you want a good (US) historical perspective, then read or listen to Lessig’s book, Free Culture.

Finally, if you think that the movement for copyright and patent reform is just a bunch of radical commies, then you should read Will Shetterly’s Biblical parable to see what happens when an idea/technology, ?ɬ† la McLuhan, "flips or reverses its properties into the opposite effect when pushed to its limits".

Why Moodle?

From Global Literacy is an overview of comparisons of the Moodle learning system with several others. Moodle is multilingual, SCORM compliant, based on a constructivist pedagogical model and is free (as in free beer and free source code). We (Mancomm) have been using Moodle rather successfully with a group of Montreal area nurses, who are co-developing their knowledge base on a new nursing care methodology.

Via incsub

Firefox problems

I’m having some problems with Firefox today. I can’t see my images that I have on my site, such as the one here. I have also lost the DHTML editor toolbar in Drupal. I know that it’s not a Drupal problem, because I have lost all of my Bloglines feeds too. On the other hand, everything works just fine in IE and even Opera. I have uninstalled and re-installed Firefox, but the problem continues. Any suggestions? I have already run a complete virus scan.

Update: Well it seems to be a Firefox problem and I can’t fix it. I’ve reloaded Firefox twice, even used the UK version instead of the US version. I can’t see any of my subscriptions in Bloglines and I’ve lost functions in Drupal, so it’s back to the dark side I go … Any other recommendations out there? This is weird.

Update 2: I’m now using Mozilla Navigator, and it seems to be working just fine. We’ll see.

Update 3: Have reloaded Firefox 1.0 on my XP SP2 system , but keeping Mozilla as a backup. Using shift-reload, I was able to see the functions in Drupal this time around. Didn’t work last time. Maybe it was just a chair-keyboard interface problem. Anyway, thanks for everyone’s help. Also, you may have noticed that I had allowed direct posting of anonymous comments for the last 24 hours. The online casino spammer caught on to this at 11:00 AM this morning, so they’re now turned off again.

Bridging the Chasm

Chasm2.jpg

Geoffrey Moore’s analogy of “crossing the chasm” is used a lot in information technology. Basically, the premise is that any new technology is quickly adopted by innovators and early adopters, but there is a chasm to cross in order to get the more pragmatic majority to adopt the new technology. For marketing, this is the real challenge – can the new product get widespread acceptance? In many cases (but not all) the development costs can only be recovered if the majority purchase the goods or services.

I previously referred to this model and tried to tie it to Gladwell’s “tipping point” theory. Much of my consulting work is in bridging the chasm

  1. I attempt to be an early adopter myself, and use this experience to work with the early pragmatic majority. I also use a broader definition of technology; being the application of organized and scientific knowledge to solve practical problems. I spend much of my time watching the innovators, and
  2. try to determine which of their ideas and new technologies would make sense for my clients. To do this, I have to keep trying out new tools and processes in my own work.
  3. It’s a real balancing act, trying to be on the leading edge but not the bleeding edge.

Some of the technologies that I believe are ready to cross the chasm in the next year [2005] are:

… as well as some that probably won’t get across, yet:

Update March 2006: It’s seems that the use of blogs has exploded, with Technorati’s current count at 29 million. Workflow learning has stalled a bit, while the value of informal learning is catching on. Wikis are also becoming more popular, especially those that replicate word processesors, like Writely. There also seems to be a growing interest in natural enterprises and something to replace corporatism as a guiding model, so I am more optimistic than last year.
[Picture based on Wikipedia entry.]

Comment Approval Queue

Given the increase in comment spam on this site, I have configured the comment function so that anonymous comments have to be approved before they are posted. I know that this may be a pain, but it’s my only option until I install Drupal 4.5. You should be able to log on to this site with a Drupal password (tell me if you can’t), or you can contact me and set up an account on this site.

Sorry for the inconvenience, but I’m tired of cleaning up all the spam every day.

Update: And now everything you wanted to know about comment spam and how to fight it, from Six Apart. The recommendations are specific to Movable Type, but may be of interest to others.

My First eCommerce Experience

I recently posted a link to SmartDraw at the bottom left of my website. This is a purely commercial venture on my part, and I receive a small commission for every sale of SmartDraw that occurs as a result of a purchase though this link. Someone purchased SmartDraw7 this month (thank you very much) and I will get some cash (cool). Here are the main reasons I decided to do this:

  • I have been using SmartDraw for a couple of years, and I like the product (ask me for details if you like)
  • SmartDraw is a small company, with about 25 employees, and I like helping the little guys
  • I wanted to experiment with paid ads, and see what happens

I would appreciate any feedback on my e-commerce foray, especially if you think that this detracts from my independent consultant status. I don’t intend to add more products to my nav bar, and no I don’t get any money for the Firefox banner – I just really like the product :-)

de Kerckhove: Communication in Evolution

For fans of Marshall McLuhan, or those interested in knowing more than just the phrase, “the medium is the message”, there is an excellent interview [dead link] online with Derrick de Kerckhove, Director of the McLuhan Program in Toronto. There is lots of stuff to chew on, as well as a concise overview of McLuhan’s tetradic Laws of Media:

“every new medium:

  • extends a human property (the car extends the foot);
  • obsolesces the previous medium by turning it into a sport or an form of art (the automobile turns horses and carriages into sports);
  • retrieves a much older medium that was obsolesced before (the automobile brings back the shining armour of the chevalier);
  • flips or reverses its properties into the opposite effect when pushed to its limits (the automobile, when there are too many of them, create traffic jams, that is total paralysis)”

The most enlightening for me is de Kerckhove’s view of a new kind of identity in our inter-networked world:

The key to the new identity is what I call “selving”, that is the self in progress, in becoming, as in quantum physics where “things are not, they merely tend to be”. The new identity is in perpetual formation and reformation at the moment of use and on line it is fluid and aggregative as when people meet and change their perceptions of each other during the meeting. I sometime suspect that screens were invented only for the purpose of allowing several persons, minds, identities to meet and share thinking and speaking at a distance. The new connective thinking system is the screen. Via What is the Message? [dead link]

Comment Spam

I’m getting a lot of comment spam from some low-life who is sticking links to an internet gambling site on my blogs. They’re easy to find & erase with Drupal, but still a pain. I like Alan Levine’s solution to disrupt comment spammers, and perhaps I’ll enlist the help of the International Spam Counter Attack Force (SCAF):

They have tools and techniques I could never understand, but with their help, our Trackback scripts were modified to collect some interesting data from our roach visitor. The people who act as local agents for SCAF have the ability to unleash a series of strikes on this person, their assets, records, etc, and once I give the go ahead, the trigger is set to go off at a random time in the future, maybe today, tomorrow, next week, a few months from now.

I’m open to comments and criticism on my blog, but completely unrelated comments that link to a gambling site are not acceptable. Since I pay to maintain this site, it’s my editorial privilege to keep it clean. Here are the multiple hosts from which this roach posts:

61.62.229.235
165.173.60.25
212.234.28.89
195.194.158.17
12.43.53.137
198.252.39.226
81.169.133.166
66.91.206.165
68.44.79.29
193.252.229.134
136.183.135.54
62.47.166.17

17 Dec: And the roach struck again early this morning (already removed) – any Drupal experts have suggestions?